Showing posts with label asean. Show all posts
Showing posts with label asean. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

South China Sea: Learning from Cold War Episodes

South China Sea was one of the more prominent flashpoints in 2012 and is likely to remain one as we start 2013. As I pored over news reports of new military exercises, deployment of troops and military hardwares (all of which are driven in one way or another by the US) to countries in the region, I can’t help but to compare this episode to those that happened during the Cold War era.

When Castro took control of Cuba and purchased crude oils from Soviet Union for processing, the reluctance of US oil companies based in Cuba to process the oils had the unintended effect of pushing Castro more towards Soviet Union and the eventual Cuban missile crisis. Similarly, Johnson’s operation rolling thunder and policies towards the peasants in then South Vietnam pushed them further towards the embrace of Communist North instead of convincing them of the ideals of freedom and democracy.

In both episodes, US’ hawkish stances had the unexpected effect of pushing these countries closer towards their rival instead of bringing them to the negotiation tables, where the probability of outcomes more favorable to the US would have been conceived. In our current South China Sea issue, China appears to have adopted similar hawkish attitude as the US did for the above episodes. I am not entirely sure if China realizes that if this behaviour is to continue, history may repeat itself; in other words, China will end up pushing their neighbours closer to the US and concurrently, give more boosts for Obama’s pivot to Asia.

In China’s interest, the sensible thing will be to tone down the rhetoric and find a middle ground to solve the issue. China had accumulated lots of neighbourly goodwill in the past and it is certainly not worth it to throw them away over a single episode.

Saturday, December 22, 2012

Report Card for the 21st ASEAN Summit

The ASEAN Summit was concluded almost a month ago. I had wanted to provide a report card of the summit but was delayed until now. As I see it, there were about four main takeaways, each capable of generating endless debate as to whether it is a good or bad thing.

First in the list is the signing of the ASEAN Human Rights Declaration. For many people, it is indeed an achievement considering that the organization did not come into being with the idea of pushing for human rights. In fact, some would even argue that many of the founders of ASEAN were hardly democratically elected. Yet, some would say that the declaration fell short of expectations as many “standard” norms appear to have been excluded.

Second is the ASEAN Economic Community (AEC). As with other recent summits, ASEAN Leaders pledged their continuous commitment to the establishment of AEC in 2015 but implementation process has been hit with several problems. The decision to delay AEC from 1 Jan 2015 to 31 Dec 2015 further proves this point. Officials can argue that AEC will still come into existence in 2015 but seriously, it is not hard to see that it has effectively been delayed by one year and how that will further affect ASEAN’s credibility remain to be seen.

Third is the announcement of the start of Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) negotiation. On one hand, it gives the impression that ASEAN is serious in pursuing further economic integration with its neighbours but on the other hand, people are questioning whether anything tangible will come out of this considering the proposed timeline of its conclusion, 2015. One, it essentially clashes with AEC and if you cannot even implement one thing with your existing resources, what can you possibly achieve when you need to divide the same resources to handle two things concurrently. Two, there is a potential impact of South China Sea issue on the negotiation process.

This brings us quite nicely to the fourth and last takeaway, which is the South China Sea issue itself. Unlike the above takeaways where something positive can be distilled from them, I frankly do not see anything positive in this issue. It has wrecked ASEAN unity. It has resulted in several incidents that are likely to increase tensions. It has kick-started some military maneuvers and God knows what will come next.

To conclude, this is not a perfect report card but this is not a bad one either. There are certainly troubles brewing but if the relevant stakeholders can just take one step back and look at the bigger picture, I believe ASEAN can right the wrongs and still come out blazing.

P.S: I survive the end of the world.

Saturday, July 21, 2012

Will ASEAN Lose Out From The Trilateral FTA Between China, Japan and Korea?

Sometime ago, China, Japan and Korea finally agreed to kick-start talks that would lead to a Free Trade Agreement (FTA) between them. This move brings about two contrasting views. For the optimists, it shows that the 3 countries are finally ready to put behind their historical enmity in the name of economic growth. For the pessimists, particularly those that believe in ASEAN centrality, it is the beginning of the end of ASEAN’s role in providing neutral ground for the 3 countries to negotiate and engage one another, especially if bilateral communications on some matters are close to impossible.

On the economic front, the pessimists fear that the expanded market size of this FTA would reduce ASEAN’s competitiveness when it comes into being. I would like to argue the opposite. China is such a huge market that it does not really need to add Japan and Korea’s population to its investment attraction strategies in order to attract more investments. In other words, firms that find China as a prospective investment location would not have waited until now before making their moves. They would have done so long time ago. There is certainly a value for Japan and Korea use the expanded market size to attract more investments but given the high labor costs in both countries, I doubt expanded market size is a strong pull factor by itself.

Then, there are those who said that ASEAN may be left out of the East Asian fortress since the FTA does not involve them. But this is an unlikely event since ASEAN has arguably pre-empt this by having FTA with each of them. I will also argue that the regional production networks that have been developed and nurtured over the years is not something that can be altered overnight, more so if there is no basis to do so at all.

Last but not least, the talk is only about to start and most definitely has not yielded anything tangible. For all the commotion, it may end up being another FTA that is trade-light and more driven by politics rather than economics.

Sunday, March 4, 2012

The Intrique of Achieving an ASEAN Community: The Middle Countries

Dr. Surin Pitsuwan, the current ASEAN Secretary General once said that it is countries in the middle that impede the progress towards building an ASEAN community. Why did he make such a remark?

Countries at the top are more than willing to take part in the establishment of community, in particular economic community because they are already highly competitive. A community will allow them better access to the neighboring market and they are certainly not worried that they will lose out in terms of efficiency if they open their borders to freer trade among ASEAN member economies.

Similarly, countries at the bottom are also more than willing to take part in this endeavor because after having been isolated for periods of time, they want to plug themselves into the globalized world and joining the ASEAN community is certainly a good starting point for doing so.

Countries in the middle view things rather differently. Opening their markets to freer trade is bound to benefit some groups but at the same time, is going to hurt some groups and these are not weak groups. Having been protected by their governments, they have grown into strong interest groups capable of influencing government policies. They would definitely prefer to maintain the status quo so as to maintain their current level of wealth and benefits.

Saturday, February 25, 2012

The Two Camps of ASEAN Cooperation Efforts

In my opinion, an inter-governmental organization needs to accomplish two things to be well respected: 1) the ability to convince the various stakeholders, each with their own interests and goals, to come to a consensus and put it in writing as agreements, frameworks, etc and 2) the strength to enforce them even if they may result in displeasure among some of the stakeholders.

ASEAN as an organization has certainly come a long way. While its founding was barely reported in the media and many were rather skeptical in its ability to achieve something noteworthy, ASEAN now has its own charter and can claim credits for numerous initiatives & mechanisms such as the Enhanced Dispute Settlement Mechanism (ESDM) and ASEAN Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights (AICHR). These are definitely no mean feat, taking into consideration the diversity of the Member States that constitute ASEAN. Hence, the natural step would have been to ask the question on whether they are enforceable or whether they are binding at all.

A closer look at these initiatives & mechanisms would give the impression that they are “toothless”. At this point, optimists like to argue that although they are symbolic in nature, they nonetheless inform us of the inspirations or the goals of the signatories. In other words, we should applaud them for having the courage to put their signatures on something that clearly contradict their domestic environments. Pessimists, on the other hand, argue that precisely because signatories know very well that there will be no consequences for deviation that they have no qualms in putting down their signatures. Both arguments are plausible and you choose a side depending on your inclination. 

Sunday, October 23, 2011

The Case for ASEAN Trade & Investment Centre

While the worst is over and the global economy is slowly recovering, there is an ongoing perception among the export economies that they can no longer rely on the traditional markets such as US and Europe to sustain their long-term growth. Consequently, the focus of many policy-makers has been on increasing domestic consumption and looking for alternative markets for their exports.

ASEAN economies take this view seriously considering that 600 million people call the region home. The dynamism of the region where each economy complements one another provide another valid reason as to why ASEAN should not only look outward in sustaining its economic growth. Among the many proposals that are circulating around is one on the establishment of a one-stop trade & investment centre (TIC) in each economy who will liaise with its counterpart in the other economies. While the idea is good in theory and should definitely be assessed critically, it may encounter several roadblocks in the immediate short-run and this is ironically due to the region’s dynamism.

Let’s start with the more developed economies. It is unlikely that these economies will shoot down the idea due to ideological clash. Afterall, economies such as Singapore pride itself as an open economy. It is open to more foreign investments and concurrently, does not spare any efforts in getting their homegrown companies to internationalize. The issue is that having stayed true to this belief for a long time, Singapore already has well-established institutions with the same responsibilities as TIC albeit under different roofs. It may thus reject this idea on the ground of redundancy. We can of course argue that instead of establishing a new centre altogether, Singapore can try to re-structure its existing institutions so that it resembles the proposed TIC but why should it do so if it has done well based on the existing model. In other words, convincing these economies will not be an easy task if we want them to buy this idea beyond solidarity.

Moving on to the less developed economies, there is no disagreement that market access is a good thing for their homegrown companies but market access is based on reciprocity. The issue with these economies is that although they want to “take” (in terms of gaining more market access), they are less willing to “give” (in terms of opening their own market) for fear that their companies are unable to compete with others. The trick is then on how we can convince them that the long-term gains far outweighs the short-term losses.