Showing posts with label trade. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trade. Show all posts

Saturday, July 21, 2012

Will ASEAN Lose Out From The Trilateral FTA Between China, Japan and Korea?

Sometime ago, China, Japan and Korea finally agreed to kick-start talks that would lead to a Free Trade Agreement (FTA) between them. This move brings about two contrasting views. For the optimists, it shows that the 3 countries are finally ready to put behind their historical enmity in the name of economic growth. For the pessimists, particularly those that believe in ASEAN centrality, it is the beginning of the end of ASEAN’s role in providing neutral ground for the 3 countries to negotiate and engage one another, especially if bilateral communications on some matters are close to impossible.

On the economic front, the pessimists fear that the expanded market size of this FTA would reduce ASEAN’s competitiveness when it comes into being. I would like to argue the opposite. China is such a huge market that it does not really need to add Japan and Korea’s population to its investment attraction strategies in order to attract more investments. In other words, firms that find China as a prospective investment location would not have waited until now before making their moves. They would have done so long time ago. There is certainly a value for Japan and Korea use the expanded market size to attract more investments but given the high labor costs in both countries, I doubt expanded market size is a strong pull factor by itself.

Then, there are those who said that ASEAN may be left out of the East Asian fortress since the FTA does not involve them. But this is an unlikely event since ASEAN has arguably pre-empt this by having FTA with each of them. I will also argue that the regional production networks that have been developed and nurtured over the years is not something that can be altered overnight, more so if there is no basis to do so at all.

Last but not least, the talk is only about to start and most definitely has not yielded anything tangible. For all the commotion, it may end up being another FTA that is trade-light and more driven by politics rather than economics.

Sunday, April 15, 2012

Is Plurilateral the Way Forward?

Many trade experts have suggested ways to move forward following the deadlock in the Doha Round. Chiefly among them is for smaller groups of countries to negotiate and implement policies that they can then extend to other WTO members as and when they are ready. The simple argument behind this proposal is that agreement can be reached faster and easier among smaller number of negotiating countries. The question is: can multilateralization really be achieved at faster rate via this proposal, as is suggested, or is it going to further burden the already complex environment? In other words, is this a building or stumbling block?

Let me give a negative perspective of this proposal. When countries negotiate, they do so from their own perspectives, taking into account their own interests. One can argue that although agreement can be reached more efficiently, the contents are probably narrower in a sense that it takes into account only the interests of the negotiating countries. If this agreement is to be eventually extended to other WTO members, will they take it at face value? Well, perhaps not since their interests have most likely not been included in the first place. When the time comes, these members will want to amend some parts of the agreement before they will subscribe to it. However, will the original negotiating countries agree since they will have to concede on some points.

Saturday, March 17, 2012

Is Race To The Bottom a Valid Reason for Standard Harmonization?

Just as there are many valid reasons against standard harmonization, there are also many credible reasons for it. But there is one reason for standard harmonization that I just can’t get around: the idea of preventing race to the bottom. The argument goes that in the current globalized world where it is so much easier for firms to relocate their production plants to low-cost locations, firms with existing plants in countries with higher standards (higher cost) can easily shift them to countries with lower standards (lower cost), resulting in job losses. To prevent such a move, countries with higher standards will revise down their requirements and spark a race to the bottom, causing lower standards across the world.

My gripe is driven by the fact that there is no clear evidence where countries have lowered their standards in order to prevent job losses. On the other hand, most countries benefiting from FDI appear to have raised their standards, partly driven by the more demanding middle class whose population share has increased. A point of note is a recent article about how Apple has raised the labour standards in China. Although critics may say that it is a one-off event caused by the widespread negative publicity, it is also correct to say that China has come a long way with regards to how it treats its labour force. Among them, the 2008 labour contract law should ring a bell to most people, not to mention the latest promise by China’s Cabinet to raise minimum wage by 13 percent a year until 2015.

Wednesday, August 24, 2011

Between Removal of Tariff Barriers and Improvements in Trade Facilitation

Both removal of tariff barriers and improvements in trade facilitation have been promoted as ways to boost trade between countries. At first glance, they appear to have more or less similar impact on a particular country, regardless of whether it is a developed or developing country. After all, removal of import tax by its partner is likely to make its export more competitive relative to domestic products whether it is a developed or developing country. The same can be said with regards to improvements in trade facilitation. It is challenging to argue that they have little impact on say the developing country.

However, there is a possibility that removal of tariff barriers is likely to benefit developing countries more than developed countries and vice versa in the case of improvements in trade facilitation. The developed countries arguably have more efficient production capabilities than the developing countries. It is thus highly likely that their products remain competitive even without removal of tariff barriers by their partners, notably the developing countries. On the other hand, the less efficient production capabilities of the developing countries necessarily mean that they have to rely on removal of tariff barriers to make their products competitive relative to others.

Moving on to improvements in trade facilitation, we have to understand the motivation of each. In the case of developed countries, improvements means better infrastructure and hence better market access. Essentially, improvements in trade facilitation by their partners increase the size of the potential market. On the contrary, companies in the developing countries that are interested in exporting their products would have selected suitable locations to site their facilities ex-ante. In other words, although improvements in trade facilitation have positive impact in general, they are unlikely to be relevant to these companies. Critics may argue that better infrastructure also mean better market access for the domestic companies but considering that infrastructure development has been rather slow or non-existent until recently, there is definitely a possibility that these companies have developed indigenous mechanisms that are not reliant on better infrastructure to improve their market access.

Presented with the above, one wonders if this could be the main reason why developed countries have been stronger advocates of improvements in trade facilitation as compared to their developing peers.

Thursday, August 18, 2011

Trade Liberalization in Asia

Asia has been rather active to the call of trade liberalization. Numerous trade agreements at bilateral as well as regional levels have been signed to the point that Asia is perhaps the reason “noodle-bowl syndrome” was coined. Moving on, what should Asian Leaders focus on? Here’s my take:

1. Look at realizing the full potential of existing trade agreements rather than signing more. Many of the trade agreements are very heavy on removal of tariff barriers. Perhaps, they should now work on removing non-tariff barriers and improving trade facilitation.
2. Engage the private sectors more because ultimately, these are the end-users of the agreements. Many of the small and medium enterprises (SMEs) appear to be in the dark of how they can utilize and benefit from these agreements.
3. Resolve the “noodle-bowl syndrome”. This will result in more efficient utilization of the trade agreements. Additionally, this is perhaps a bottom-up approach to getting a consensus at the international level.