Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 2, 2013

What Does The Process of Averting Fiscal Cliff Tell Us About American Politics?

The media may have hailed the aversion of America’s fiscal cliff for the time being. However, a deeper look at the process leading to it tells us of how bad partisan politics has become in Washington and could very well foretell what to expect for Obama’s second term.

While the automatic tax increases and spending cuts were supposed to kick in on 1st January, lawmakers on both sides dragged the process of passing the legislation until the dawn of 2nd January because in theory, anything on paper could not be acted upon until people came back to work. While making a formal notice to Congress that the Government would hit its borrowing limit on 31st December, Geithner mentioned that the Treasury Department could avoid action for additional two months through creative accounting.

Although such behaviours indicate the perseverance of lawmakers in trying to exploit any loopholes to ensure that they get the best deals for the people that they are representing, it also points to significant differences between two sides to a level that neither is willing to compromise till the very last moment or rather, till there are no more tricks up their sleeve. When one looks at this, one wonders how America will tackle more difficult issues, especially those requiring bipartisan cooperation and compromise.

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

South China Sea: Learning from Cold War Episodes

South China Sea was one of the more prominent flashpoints in 2012 and is likely to remain one as we start 2013. As I pored over news reports of new military exercises, deployment of troops and military hardwares (all of which are driven in one way or another by the US) to countries in the region, I can’t help but to compare this episode to those that happened during the Cold War era.

When Castro took control of Cuba and purchased crude oils from Soviet Union for processing, the reluctance of US oil companies based in Cuba to process the oils had the unintended effect of pushing Castro more towards Soviet Union and the eventual Cuban missile crisis. Similarly, Johnson’s operation rolling thunder and policies towards the peasants in then South Vietnam pushed them further towards the embrace of Communist North instead of convincing them of the ideals of freedom and democracy.

In both episodes, US’ hawkish stances had the unexpected effect of pushing these countries closer towards their rival instead of bringing them to the negotiation tables, where the probability of outcomes more favorable to the US would have been conceived. In our current South China Sea issue, China appears to have adopted similar hawkish attitude as the US did for the above episodes. I am not entirely sure if China realizes that if this behaviour is to continue, history may repeat itself; in other words, China will end up pushing their neighbours closer to the US and concurrently, give more boosts for Obama’s pivot to Asia.

In China’s interest, the sensible thing will be to tone down the rhetoric and find a middle ground to solve the issue. China had accumulated lots of neighbourly goodwill in the past and it is certainly not worth it to throw them away over a single episode.

Saturday, December 22, 2012

Report Card for the 21st ASEAN Summit

The ASEAN Summit was concluded almost a month ago. I had wanted to provide a report card of the summit but was delayed until now. As I see it, there were about four main takeaways, each capable of generating endless debate as to whether it is a good or bad thing.

First in the list is the signing of the ASEAN Human Rights Declaration. For many people, it is indeed an achievement considering that the organization did not come into being with the idea of pushing for human rights. In fact, some would even argue that many of the founders of ASEAN were hardly democratically elected. Yet, some would say that the declaration fell short of expectations as many “standard” norms appear to have been excluded.

Second is the ASEAN Economic Community (AEC). As with other recent summits, ASEAN Leaders pledged their continuous commitment to the establishment of AEC in 2015 but implementation process has been hit with several problems. The decision to delay AEC from 1 Jan 2015 to 31 Dec 2015 further proves this point. Officials can argue that AEC will still come into existence in 2015 but seriously, it is not hard to see that it has effectively been delayed by one year and how that will further affect ASEAN’s credibility remain to be seen.

Third is the announcement of the start of Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) negotiation. On one hand, it gives the impression that ASEAN is serious in pursuing further economic integration with its neighbours but on the other hand, people are questioning whether anything tangible will come out of this considering the proposed timeline of its conclusion, 2015. One, it essentially clashes with AEC and if you cannot even implement one thing with your existing resources, what can you possibly achieve when you need to divide the same resources to handle two things concurrently. Two, there is a potential impact of South China Sea issue on the negotiation process.

This brings us quite nicely to the fourth and last takeaway, which is the South China Sea issue itself. Unlike the above takeaways where something positive can be distilled from them, I frankly do not see anything positive in this issue. It has wrecked ASEAN unity. It has resulted in several incidents that are likely to increase tensions. It has kick-started some military maneuvers and God knows what will come next.

To conclude, this is not a perfect report card but this is not a bad one either. There are certainly troubles brewing but if the relevant stakeholders can just take one step back and look at the bigger picture, I believe ASEAN can right the wrongs and still come out blazing.

P.S: I survive the end of the world.

Sunday, September 2, 2012

Economic Slowdown and Nationalistic Behaviour

Two weeks ago, I mentioned that the Chinese economy is still very much reliant on demand from the West and alluded that it was not really domestic consumption boost or successful diversification, but rather false expectations about the speedy recovery in EU and US that had contributed to the outside appearance that Asia, particularly China has successfully decoupled itself from the West sometime ago when Asia seemed to be doing pretty well as opposed to EU and US (More on Decoupling and Asia).

The latest data released on the Chinese economic slowdown and the need to clear existing inventories served to prove this point. Indeed, an article by Damian Grammaticas from BBC gave some examples of industries where the number of days to clear inventories have increased exponentially.

In that pervious post, I made a passing (and cautious) remark that the Chinese government can consider learning a thing or two from Indonesia, which has been able to drive economic growth by boosting domestic consumption. Learning from Indonesia is one thing. Question is: has the government ever considered boosting domestic consumption as an option to pick up the slack from EU and US? Judging from its past actions, it certainly has. However, boosting domestic consumption is not a free lunch. While they largely fulfill their objectives, interest rate cut and the likes also lead to inflation, default, etc, things that the government has been trying to put a lid on.

Even if they have certain mechanisms in mind to counteract these unwanted side-effects, they may want to tone it down and give the limelight for solving the economic slowdown to the new generation of leaders that are expected to take over the country later this year.

So when you want to do something that will impact your population but can’t really do it for economic and political reasons, the simplest way is to divert the attention of the population away from it. Perhaps this is the reason why China has become more nationalists with regards to South China Sea and other nearby waters in the past few months.

Sunday, August 26, 2012

Decentralization in China: Lessons from Gu Kailai

Gu Kailai, wife of Bo Xilai, a former rising star of the Chinese Communist Party, was sentenced to death with a two-year delay last Monday. After the announcement, the focus of the media was on how it was a foregone conclusion and speculations arose about when Bo himself will be charged and if so, what his likely sentence will be.

What’s interesting to me is that no one actually bothered to analyze something that is very much the norm in most countries but is different in China, especially when it comes to court cases; that is the location where Gu was charged. Generally, the accused is charged by the court in the jurisdiction where the alleged crime took place. But here, we have someone who allegedly committed the crime in Chongqing, but charged by the court in Hefei, Anhui, which is a totally different city and province altogether. Why is this so?

When I read the book entitled “The Party” by Richard McGregor, I found that this action has precedent in the case of Chen Liangyu, the former Party Secretary of Shanghai who was charged in 2008. Chen was charged in Changchun, Jilin, also a totally different city and province from the alleged crime. The explanation given in the book was that Changchun was far away from Shanghai and that Shanghai judges could not be trusted to follow Beijing’s order. If this is indeed true, then Beijing has valid reasons for assigning the court in Hefei to charge Gu.

However, I have not brought up this observation simply to explain Beijing’s decision. Rather, what I want to say is that decentralization in China has reached a level where the perception that Beijing still has a strong grip on whatever that is going on in the country is no longer true. The system has been structured in such a way that the highest position in a specific region has a say in almost everything that goes on that he/she is effectively the “ruler” of that fiefdom, up to the point that it is beyond the control of Beijing. Isn’t it ironic for a Government who likes to portray that it has everything under control?

Sunday, April 8, 2012

Guarded Optimism for Post-Election Myanmar

The final tally of the by-election in Myanmar is out! The National League for Democracy (NLD) led by Aung San Suu Kyi won 43 out of the 44 seats that were contested. But is this the end by itself? Well, I would think of it as a step in the right direction but definitely not an end because a lot of uncertainties remain despite the historic event.

Firstly, while there is no doubt in her ability to inspire people, a lot of questions on Aung San Suu Kyi’s capabilities to run a country or rather contribute to the running of the country have been raised. This is not surprising considering that she is untested and spent a considerable time under house arrest.

Secondly, even if she is highly capable, critics have questioned her ability to influence key decisions made by the government since the NLD only holds approximately 5% of the parliamentary seats.

Thirdly, while President Thein Sein seems to be highly supportive of the political reform in Myanmar, there have been questions on how much influence he has over the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) and how much power still resides with the military. There is always a possibility of a coup if he cannot convince them that he is right; Myanmar is afterall no stranger to coups.

Although the result of the by-election certainly deserves applause, the path ahead is far from smooth.

Sunday, March 25, 2012

The Importance of Aung San Suu Kyi

The opening of Myanmar has been on the news for several weeks, if not months now. Slowly, the world will know more than Aung San Suu Kyi. But for now, let us talk about this lady who is the embodiment of Myanmar itself. I may be wrong in making this conjecture but many people seem to have this question: “If Aung San Suu Kyi was such a threat to the military junta, why did the military never consider eliminating her?” I am sure the military considered this option but never really got to the path of executing it. Why?

First was the domestic consideration. Aung San Suu Kyi is the daughter of General Aung San, who became a strong symbol of opposition to the military after he was assassinated. The military was afraid that if something untoward was to happen to Aung San Suu Kyi as well, it would galvanize the opposition to such a level that even they would not be able to handle despite having the advantage of firepower.

Second was the international consideration. Through the sheer effort of Michael Aris, the late husband of Aung San Suu Kyi, she became and still is the face of Myanmar to the world. As such, the policies of the external powers, notably the Western world, were very much tied to their assessments of how Aung San Suu Kyi was treated by the regime. If they carried things too far, the international pressure could be so strong that their existence itself could not be guaranteed.

Although power has been transferred to the nominally civilian government, there is no doubt that the military still lurks in the background. The chances of them reading this entry is very slim but if they do, I hope they will consider the implications of their action if the thought of eliminating Aung San Suu Kyi ever comes again.   

Sunday, March 4, 2012

The Intrique of Achieving an ASEAN Community: The Middle Countries

Dr. Surin Pitsuwan, the current ASEAN Secretary General once said that it is countries in the middle that impede the progress towards building an ASEAN community. Why did he make such a remark?

Countries at the top are more than willing to take part in the establishment of community, in particular economic community because they are already highly competitive. A community will allow them better access to the neighboring market and they are certainly not worried that they will lose out in terms of efficiency if they open their borders to freer trade among ASEAN member economies.

Similarly, countries at the bottom are also more than willing to take part in this endeavor because after having been isolated for periods of time, they want to plug themselves into the globalized world and joining the ASEAN community is certainly a good starting point for doing so.

Countries in the middle view things rather differently. Opening their markets to freer trade is bound to benefit some groups but at the same time, is going to hurt some groups and these are not weak groups. Having been protected by their governments, they have grown into strong interest groups capable of influencing government policies. They would definitely prefer to maintain the status quo so as to maintain their current level of wealth and benefits.

Saturday, February 25, 2012

The Two Camps of ASEAN Cooperation Efforts

In my opinion, an inter-governmental organization needs to accomplish two things to be well respected: 1) the ability to convince the various stakeholders, each with their own interests and goals, to come to a consensus and put it in writing as agreements, frameworks, etc and 2) the strength to enforce them even if they may result in displeasure among some of the stakeholders.

ASEAN as an organization has certainly come a long way. While its founding was barely reported in the media and many were rather skeptical in its ability to achieve something noteworthy, ASEAN now has its own charter and can claim credits for numerous initiatives & mechanisms such as the Enhanced Dispute Settlement Mechanism (ESDM) and ASEAN Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights (AICHR). These are definitely no mean feat, taking into consideration the diversity of the Member States that constitute ASEAN. Hence, the natural step would have been to ask the question on whether they are enforceable or whether they are binding at all.

A closer look at these initiatives & mechanisms would give the impression that they are “toothless”. At this point, optimists like to argue that although they are symbolic in nature, they nonetheless inform us of the inspirations or the goals of the signatories. In other words, we should applaud them for having the courage to put their signatures on something that clearly contradict their domestic environments. Pessimists, on the other hand, argue that precisely because signatories know very well that there will be no consequences for deviation that they have no qualms in putting down their signatures. Both arguments are plausible and you choose a side depending on your inclination. 

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

Behind the Protest on Camar Bulan and Tanjung Datu

Being countries that share borders which span for thousands of miles, Indonesia and Malaysia have had their fair share of neighborly argument. The last one involves the area of Camar Bulan and Tanjung Datu in West Kalimantan which Indonesians claim to have been “snatched” by the Malaysians. To show their displeasure, several social organizations staged a protest in front of the Malaysian High Commission in Jakarta. As the protest went on, emotions ran high and physical scuffles began.

For those that are against the protest, such acts are an embarrassment to the Indonesian Government who pledged to settle any disagreements on the negotiating tables. To make matters worse, the protesters are not people from the affected area, whom by argument have the right to show their unhappiness. The point is if the affected people do not protest, why should these people protest? Others are more critical, saying that these people are just politicizing the entire issue for their own benefits.

However, one can also look at this entire episode from another angle. Although these protesters are not from the affected area, they are Indonesians by birth and hence have the rights to fight for lands that they believe should belong to Indonesia regardless of whether they are from the area or not. To put it simply, it is a case of by Indonesians for Indonesia.

Additionally, one can also argue from the perspective that these people are simply taking over the role of the Indonesian Government, both central and regional, who have the authority and right to make their displeasure known to their neighbour. These people are effectively replacing the Government whom they feel is not firm enough on acts that breach the sovereignty of the nation.

Saturday, August 20, 2011

India and International Aid

A couple of weeks ago, I found out that India has established its own international aid agency. While this shows a country that is rising and ready to do more globally, I can’t help but to pour cold water into this perception. India is a developing country where a large percentage of its population still live below the poverty line. Wander around the big cities and you will see slums as well as how the dwellers make ends meet. Travel to the countryside and you will see many villages whose Gram Panchayat are not carrying out their duties and roads which are supposed to be repaired but for some reasons have been left as they are among others. If you have the time to have conversations with the villagers, you will realize that they have long lost trust in their government. So if India really has the capability to help others, why not help its own people?

Resources and politics appear to be the two main culprits. Its fast-growing economy means that it is likely to need more resources. In this aspect, India seems to have picked up the strategy of China, its neighbour or some would say rival. The Chinese has built excellent relationships with its African counterparts. In return for access to their wealthy resources, the Chinese has promised infrastructure development. Through its newly established aid agency, I believe India hopes to replicate China’s success in courting the Africans. Additionally, in an ever-integrated world where many issues are discussed at global forums, India may hope to gain supporters for its agenda.

In its pursuit for “bigger” reasons which I have to acknowledge are valid, the Indian Government appear to have forgotten the welfare of its own people, the very people who put them into power. The two things are not mutually exclusive. There are definitely ways to achieve both and I think India should seriously explore such options.

Tuesday, August 2, 2011

Freedom and Growth

The long-running downturn in the Western world and the resilient Asian economies, many of which are nominally democratic have inadvertently churned out the idea of political freedom or economic growth. This is most definitely a very foreign concept in the minds of many people in the West. Indeed, for decades and even centuries, the West has showed us that the two can co-exist and in fact, quite possibly complement each other. There is no doubt that we should not play down Asia’s achievement but is it too soon or is it even right to make political freedom and economic growth mutually exclusive?

At the heart of this idea is the belief that something productive would have been achieved as opposed to time wasted in endless negotiations among politicians in a democracy. Of course, here I am assuming a situation where no single party hold a majority in a parliament and a consensus among the relevant players need to be reached. A very recent example is perhaps the current impasse in US about raising the debt ceiling. Going by the argument and the potential impact that a default may have on the global economy as a whole, would the US have been better off if it abandons democracy altogether?

I think we need to take a step back and ask ourselves what democracy is all about. No doubt economic growth is important but in our quest for this growth, we seem to have been blinded and forgotten what democracy is all about to the extent that we made the two mutually exclusive. It is about collective decision-making. It is about taking into consideration the views of different people, different segments of the society. Surely, it does not imply that it impedes economic growth at any point in time. In fact, inclusivity could have resulted in a more balanced growth. Afterall, who are we to judge that our decisions are the best for the nation? Or superior over the others?

Even if at the end of the day, political freedom and economic growth are indeed mutually exclusive, in reaching a consensus, isn’t it worthwhile to sacrifice a bit of economic growth?

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Unipolar or bipolar?

My father once told me that when the world was bipolar, Indonesia had one of the strongest military in the southern hemisphere. Then, I could not understand why that was the case because I was born and spend my entire life in a unipolar world. Recent events however have made me understand things better.

To put it quite simply, you cannot play one power against another in a unipolar world but can do so in a bipolar world. When one does not want to provide you with assistance, you always have the alternative option of engaging the other. The lack of military assistance provided to the East Timorese by the Australian has led them to request for assistance from China. In a unipolar world, there will be no gunboats and army barracks for the East Timorese. Additionally, in light of the delay in the funding promised by several developed nations to the Libyan Transitional National Council, one wonders if the ongoing visit by Mustafa Abdel-Jalil to China has got anything to do with this.

Whether the desired wishes of countries are good or bad remain open to debate. What is clear is that these wishes are more likely to be fulfilled in a bipolar world.

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Is WFP Redundant?

I attended the World Food Programme (WFP) talk last week to understand more about its mission and vision. WFP is one of the largest NGO that provides food aid to people all around the world, particularly Africa. Despite its high profile, it is ironic to find that many countries are not willing to support its cause. One of the main reasons, I am guessing, is that WFP’s mission is analogous to giving fishes to poor and able people rather than teaching them how to fish. In other words, its mission does not make its targeted population self-sufficient/ self-sustainable in the long run. Worse, it may make turn them into a bunch of lazy people who are heavily reliant on external help for survival.

I personally share the views of these countries. And I think we should be contented to find that there’s another UN agency, Food and Agriculture Organization that looks into teaching these people to be self-supporting. However, does this mean that there’s no longer any role for WFP in this world? Well, not really.

We have to understand that it takes time for the measures put in place by Food and Agriculture Organization to yield some results. During the period between implementation and outcome, we still need to provide food to these people and no other agencies can do the job better than WFP.

In addition, we have to consider situations such as natural disasters, wars, etc where the only viable option is to provide direct food aid to the victims.

Sunday, October 11, 2009

My Take on Obama's Copenhagen Trip

There has been a big hoo-ha on Obama’s trip to Copenhagen to do his bit for Chicago. Personally, I think that he should not have made the trip because of 2 main reasons:

1) It is a well-known fact that the Games have never been staged in South America and since Brazil is one of the participating countries for the 2016 Games bid, it is highly likely that Brazil would win the bid. Since that’s the case, the President’s trip to Copenhagen would not only be futile but would also waste taxpayers’ money (not to mention the contribution of the flight to the carbon output which he has been fighting to reduce all these while.)

2) There are many things in Washington that needs his attention. The healthcare issue is obviously one of them. Going to Copenhagen at such a crucial time would only give his opponents more ammunition to be used against him. As expected, many of them have started to say that this is indeed the behaviour of a President who doesn’t know how to prioritize.

Friday, October 2, 2009

Can China Accept the Effects of Increasing Usage of RMB Globally?

I read an article in the Economist today which says that the Chinese government has a desire to increase use of its currency for international trade and finance. I must say I am really amazed by this desire because it simply means that the government must loosen its monetary policies, particularly those with regard to foreign exchange. For a long, long time, the government has kept a tight control on its monetary policies to promote export and for fear that foreign agents might manipulate the value of RMB. It isn’t easy to bring a large amount of RMB out of China and until a few years ago, it wasn’t even possible to exchange RMB to another currency freely in China.

With the about turn, it seems that the Chinese government has changed its mindset because increasing usage of a currency globally will without doubt mean that the particular currency must be revalued (something that the Chinese government has been dragging all the while because of its negative impact on export) and will be more susceptible to external manipulation (essentially losing absolute control of its currency). The Chinese government must be very confident that its huge reserves will be able to counteract any ill intent towards the RMB.

Thursday, October 1, 2009

The Need for Trade-Off: What I Like About Policy Formulation

“If our contribution to health care reform exceeds $80 billion, you reach a point where you risk sacrificing someone’s job for someone else’s health insurance,” Mr. Ken Johnson, SVP of the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America said about the Nelson amendment to the Health care bill.

Monday, September 28, 2009

After Healthcare, it is now the Financial Industry's Turn

A statement made by President Obama, clearly indicating that things are not going to be the same anymore for the financial industry:

“I want them to hear my words. We will not go back to the days of reckless behavior and unchecked excess at the heart of this crisis, where too many were motivated only by the appetite for quick kills and bloated bonuses.”

Sunday, September 27, 2009

Germany's Eccentric Electoral Rules

I came across an interesting article on Germany’s upcoming election in the Economist yesterday. It appears that state election in Germany is divided into 2 stages: the first one is to elect individual representatives while the second one is to elect parties to represent the state. The interesting part is that if a candidate loses in the first stage, he/she may still be able to enter Bundestag (Germany’s Parliament) if 1) his/her party win the second stage and 2) he/she is high enough in the party hierarchy at the state level.

With such kind of electoral rules, I am worried that candidates affliated to popular parties will not do their best to connect with voters in the first stage because in any case, they will still be elected in the second stage due to their party affliations. Consequently, this will result in representatives that do not really represent their constituents in the Bundestag because they are elected by virtue of their party affliations, but not by how well they can identify with the constituents’ issues.

Clearly, something must be done about these electoral rules. As a start, perhaps the relevant authorities can prevent the same candidate from taking part in both stages so as to remove the possibility of a first-stage loser from being elected in the second stage.

Friday, September 25, 2009

Alternative Way for Sen. Baucus to Protect Middle-Income People

In the current health care debate, opponents of the Baucus plan are saying that the Senator’s intention to tax Cadillac-insurance plans will end up hurting middle-income people due to the effect of inflation on insurance premium. To blunt the tax effect, Senator Baucus is expected to amend the existing bill so as to provide more subsidies to middle-income people.

Instead of doing it this way, why not increase the taxable level by the average inflation rate annually? This will ensure that the insurance premium of most middle-income people will always be below the taxable level. Administratively, this will be easier to manage as well. And for those who say that this is radical, I don’t think so because this is not the first time that governments, in particular US government, has worked with inflation issue. In fact, many governments are already issuing bonds that take into account inflation.